Skip to content
NCBNational Capability Benchmark
Navigate with โ†‘ โ†“Enter to openEsc to close

Challenge the benchmark

Choose a score and give the benchmark a specific reason to reconsider it.

When you submit, the form attaches the current score and confidence for the country and capability you chose.

Submissions are public and start as awaiting review. A maintainer can add a response and signature after review.

Documented examples

Each record describes something a country built that the indicators do not capture. The source provides the published number; the mechanism is our interpretation.

Scores describe outcomes. These records describe how a country acted, what it needed and what happened. 742 of 742 records include a mechanism. They do not affect scores.

Narrow the list

8 of 742 deliveries

Coordination

1 delivery linked to Public-private collaboration.

Thailandsince 2016still operatingbears on Public-private collaboration

PromptPay national instant-payment rail

Thailand's central bank and commercial-bank network have run PromptPay as a shared instant-payment rail since 2016; by December 2024, 87.5 million proxy numbers were registered and average daily volume reached 66.4 million transactions, with a one-day peak of 89.2 million in September.

87,500,000 registered numbers, promptpay registered proxy numbers, 2024-12. 66,400,000 transactions per day, average daily promptpay transactions, 2024. Bank of Thailand, Annual Report 2024, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

The Bank of Thailand set a common proxy-ID and QR standard, while banks connected their existing accounts and customer channels to a central registration and switching layer. That let a small merchant receive an interbank payment with a phone number or citizen ID instead of negotiating a bespoke integration with every bank.

Preconditions

  • A trusted central bank able to set an interoperable standard across competing banks
  • A shared identity or account-linking layer that resolves proxy numbers safely
  • Low-cost mobile and QR channels available to households, firms and government agencies

Where else it has been used: Fast-payment rails have travelled through bilateral links and domestic copies. Thailand's lesson is that a public standard becomes infrastructure only when private banks can reuse it at scale and the operator publishes usage and security performance.

Limits: Registration and transaction volume show a heavily used payment rail, not the distribution of access, reliability during outages, fraud losses or the share of activity that is genuinely additional to cash and cards. The Bank of Thailand reports the aggregate totals, and proxy registrations can include more than one number for a person or business. The public-private mechanism is inferred from the central-bank standard and participating-bank network rather than isolated by the report as a causal estimate.

Learning

1 delivery linked to Adult learning participation.

Thailandsince 1993still operatingbears on Adult learning participation

Department of Skill Development skill-upgrading training

Thailand's Department of Skill Development, through 86 national institutes and provincial offices, trained 91,911 workers in skill-upgrading courses in fiscal year 2023, of whom 88,656 completed, according to its open-data release.

88,656 people, workers completing skill-upgrading training (sum of male and female completers across all units), fiscal year 2566 (October 2022 to September 2023). 88,602 people, workers completing skill-upgrading training in fiscal year 2564, fiscal year 2564 (October 2020 to September 2021). Department of Skill Development, Ministry of Labour, open data portal, dataset dsd_12_01_01 'Number of workers completing skill-upgrading training' (CSV per fiscal year), retrieved 2026-10-02.

The move, and what it needed

The Ministry of Labour runs a national network of skill development institutes and provincial offices that deliver short, free upgrading courses to employed workers by occupation group, and publishes per-unit results as open data.

Preconditions

  • A labour ministry department with its own training centres in every region
  • Occupational skill standards that courses can be built against
  • An open-data mandate that makes each unit report applicants, entrants and completers

Limits: Both numbers are computed: the department publishes one row per unit and occupation group (494 rows in fiscal 2566), and the totals here are the sums of its male and female completer columns, which the department does not print as a headline. The CSV is encoded in Thai Windows code page 874, and some cells carry a thousands separator, so a sum that parses them as text undercounts. The open data stops at fiscal 2566 (2023) and covers three years only (88,602 completers in fiscal 2564, 63,785 in fiscal 2565, 88,656 in fiscal 2566), so no long trend or peak can be read from it. About 89,000 completers a year is roughly 0.2 percent of a labour force near 40 million, the courses are short, and the count is the agency reporting on itself with no outcome measure. The figures cover the department's own upgrading courses only, not pre-employment training, supplementary occupation courses, employer training claimed under the Skill Development Promotion Act, or the education ministry's non-formal education, whose portals refused connections from this research. The 1993 start date is the founding of the department as given in general references, not stated at the source URL.

Experimentation

1 delivery linked to Firms through regulatory sandboxes.

Thailandsince 2016still operatingbears on Firms through regulatory sandboxes

Bank of Thailand regulatory sandbox

The Bank of Thailand, which opened a fintech regulatory sandbox in late 2016, listed 10 sandbox project tracks as of April 2026, whose participant counts sum to 90, from QR payment (14) and biometrics (19) to letters of guarantee (18), the National Digital ID (12) and programmable payment.

10 sandbox project tracks, project tracks listed under the bank of thailand regulatory sandbox, 2026-04. 90 participants, participants summed across the listed sandbox project tracks, 2026-04. Bank of Thailand, Regulatory Sandbox page, retrieved 2026-10-01.

The move, and what it needed

The Bank of Thailand let banks, fintechs and technology providers test payment, identity and lending services under limited scope and temporary relief, then wrote what worked into rules.

Preconditions

  • A central bank with legal room to grant temporary, conditional relief and to supervise tests closely
  • Incumbent banks willing to test shared standards inside the sandbox rather than lobby against them
  • A path from a successful test to a licence or a published standard, so the sandbox is not a holding pen

Where else it has been used: Sandboxes spread across ASEAN after 2016; Thailand's variant is notable for running thematic tracks (QR, biometrics, digital ID).

Limits: The count is the regulator's own listing on a web page rendered from its CMS, not an audited statistic, and the page does not say whether the participants are live today or cumulative since each track opened: the linked P2P list includes firms that exited or discontinued (one discontinued in 2022, one in 2023), so 90 is likely cumulative, not live. The total of 90 is computed by summing the table. A track is the Bank's own grouping, so 10 tracks is not comparable to a count of sandbox regimes elsewhere. The figures show breadth of testing, not how many tests became licensed products, what was learned, or whether consumers were protected; the started year rests on a Bank of Thailand research note, not the 2016 guideline itself. Other Thai regulators' sandboxes are not counted here.

Adaptability

4 deliveries linked to Institutional responsiveness, Disaster preparedness and recovery.

Thailandsince 2002still operatingbears on Institutional responsiveness

Universal Coverage Scheme and the 30-baht health system

Thailand's National Health Security Office has sustained the tax-funded Universal Coverage Scheme since 2002; in fiscal 2023 it covered more than 47.2 million people and contracted 17,247 public and private health units to provide care.

47,200,000 people, universal coverage scheme beneficiaries, 2023. 17,247 health units, public and private health units serving ucs beneficiaries, 2023. Thailand National Health Security Office, Top 10 achievements of the NHSO in 2023, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

Thailand created a statutory national purchaser, financed coverage from the public budget and repeatedly revised the benefits package and access rules instead of treating the 2002 launch as a one-off reform. A common fund could contract a mixed provider network and use the national ID rather than a paper card to carry eligibility.

Preconditions

  • A legal entitlement and budget process that survives changes of government
  • A purchaser with data and bargaining capacity across public and private providers
  • A population register and administrative claims system that can verify eligibility

Where else it has been used: Thailand's purchaser model is studied across low- and middle-income countries. The transferable move is durable pooled financing plus an agency that can learn the benefit package, not the exact 30-baht co-payment.

Limits: Beneficiary and provider counts show institutional reach, not equal quality, timeliness, financial protection in every case or the health outcomes attributable to the scheme. NHSO is the programme manager and reports its own administrative totals; the provider count includes units with different capacities and does not show how many patients each served. The record also covers one of three tax-funded schemes, not every route to Thai health coverage.

Thailandsince 2022still operatingbears on Institutional responsiveness

National Digital ID framework

Thailand's Digital ID Framework aligned government and private identity providers around common standards in its 2022โ€“2024 first phase; the Electronic Transactions Development Agency reports at least 113 million users across the major ThaiD, Tang Rat, Paotang and NDID platforms and services.

113,000,000 users/accounts reported by platforms, users represented across major digital id platforms and services, 2024. 4 platforms, major digital id platforms included in the first-phase account base, 2024. Electronic Transactions Development Agency (ETDA), Digital ID Framework Phase 2 review, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

ETDA acted as a coordinating standards body while the interior ministry, a state bank and financial-sector network each kept a user-facing identity channel. A common framework allowed those channels to connect to government and private services without forcing the country to wait for one monolithic identity provider.

Preconditions

  • A population-data authority able to anchor identity assurance
  • A standards body with convening power across state agencies, banks and platforms
  • Security, consent and recovery rules for people who lose a device or need assisted access

Where else it has been used: Federated identity ecosystems travel more easily than a single national login, but only if the trust and liability rules are explicit. Thailand's overlapping platforms make the scale visible and the deduplication problem visible too.

Limits: The 113-million figure is an aggregate of platform-reported users and can include overlapping accounts, so it is not a count of unique people or proof that all services accept the same credential. The ETDA review describes framework progress and platform stocks, not authentication success, exclusion, security incidents or the cost of integration. The framework's second phase was still expanding its target groups and service coverage when the source was published.

Thailandsince 2025still operatingbears on Disaster preparedness and recovery

T-Alert national cell-broadcast warning system

Thailand launched T-Alert in September 2025 as a nationwide cell-broadcast warning system: it covers eight hazard categories, was built with the disaster agency, digital ministry, telecom regulator and AIS, True and NT, and followed three staged tests in 2025 before use in real floods and other incidents.

8 hazard categories, hazard categories covered by t-alert at launch, 2025-09. 3 test phases, cell-broadcast test phases completed before national rollout, 2025. Government Public Relations Department of Thailand, T-Alert launch, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

Thailand joined a disaster-warning centre to the telecom regulator, digital ministry and all three major mobile operators, using cell broadcast so the authority can target a geography without a subscriber list. Staged tests at building, district and provincial levels preceded wider use, while hazard-specific thresholds and field data determine when to alert.

Preconditions

  • A legally recognised authority able to issue a national alert through every operator
  • A common cell-broadcast gateway and compatible handset standards
  • Hazard data and local incident workflows that can turn a forecast into a bounded target area

Where else it has been used: Cell broadcast is spreading as a complement to sirens and SMS. Thailand's staged rollout shows the coordination needed to make a multi-operator warning channel real, while its handset limits keep redundancy essential.

Limits: The hazard count and test phases show a national warning architecture, not warning lead time, receipt by every at-risk person, false-alarm rates or evacuation outcomes. Cell broadcast depends on compatible 4G/5G devices and current operating systems, while older phones require another channel. The government reports the rollout and examples of use; independent tests of alert comprehension and last-mile action are still needed.

Thailandsince 2020operating below its peakbears on Disaster preparedness and recovery

Public disaster warning network of the Department of Disaster Prevention and Mitigation, and its erosion

Thailand's State Audit Office found in 2024 that the public warning system, for which the state allocated THB 1,074.95 million in fiscal years 2020 to 2022, and whose telemetry the Department of Disaster Prevention and Mitigation publishes through its DPM Alert app, was not working as intended: 318 of 555 telemetry stations (57.30%) failed to measure continuously for more than two days, and 54 of 82 sampled warning towers and receivers (65.85%) were not ready to sound an alert, which the auditor attributed to damaged or deteriorated key parts.

65.85 % of 82 devices tested in 7 provinces, sampled warning devices (towers, satellite receivers, relay stations, broadcast towers) not ready to alert, audit findings released March 2024, covering FY2020-2022. 555 stations, telemetry stations in the dpm alert warning network, the installed base the audit tested (of which 318 failed continuous measurement), audit findings released March 2024, covering FY2020-2022. State Audit Office of the Kingdom of Thailand (เธชเธณเธ™เธฑเธเธ‡เธฒเธ™เธเธฒเธฃเธ•เธฃเธงเธˆเน€เธ‡เธดเธ™เนเธœเนˆเธ™เธ”เธดเธ™), audit findings on the public disaster warning system, retrieved 2026-10-01.

The move, and what it needed

Thailand's disaster department funded and installed warning towers, telemetry and a public app, but left maintenance after warranty, data integration and provincial alerting duties without owners, so the installed network decayed into equipment that was present but not ready to sound.

Preconditions

  • A maintenance budget and named custodians for every device after the supplier warranty ends
  • A routine national test that records which towers actually sound and feeds repairs
  • Provincial and local units obliged to issue and log alerts within the warning window, with someone checking they did

Where else it has been used: Siren and telemetry networks erode the same way elsewhere once the post-disaster budget passes. Thailand's audit is unusual for counting the decay device by device, which is what made the later shift to cell broadcast an evidence-based choice rather than a fashion.

Limits: The page is hosted on the State Audit Office's own site, but it is a newspaper clipping (Siang Samphan, dated 28 March 2024) of the office's release, not the full audit report; the report itself was not opened. The release names no agency; attributing the network to DPM rests on the DPM Alert app. Part of the telemetry was still under the supplier's defect warranty, so its 57.30% failure rate is underperformance of new equipment, not decay; the erosion is carried by the tower test. The device test covers 82 devices in seven provinces chosen by the auditors, not a national random sample, so 65.85% is not a national failure rate. The 'peak' in secondMetric is the installed size of the telemetry network, not an observed year in which all 555 stations worked: the audit does not say when, or whether, the network last ran at full function, so the erosion is from design capacity rather than a measured earlier high. The started year is the first fiscal year of the audited budget window. The audit tests readiness of equipment, not outcomes in a real disaster, and it predates the September 2025 T-Alert cell-broadcast rollout recorded separately as tha-t-alert, which may have replaced part of the function. The finding of THB 514 million in poorly spent funds is the auditor's judgement of value for money.

Building

1 delivery linked to Large project delivery.

Thailandsince 1991dismantledbears on Large project delivery

Hopewell elevated road-and-rail concession, and its termination

Thailand approved Hopewell's 60-kilometre Bangkok Elevated Road and Train System concession in 1991, but work stalled at 14 percent completion for more than nine months during the 1997 property-market collapse and the government terminated the concession in spring 1998.

14 % complete, hopewell project construction progress when work stood still, 1997. 60 kilometres, planned multimodal hopewell system length, 1991. World Bank, Cities on the Move: an urban transport strategy review, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

The concession bundled transport delivery with property-development revenue and depended on continuous site handover and a rising Bangkok property market. When the boom collapsed, construction stopped, the state and concessionaire lacked a credible re-scoping path, and the government terminated the agreement rather than deliver the promised integrated system.

Preconditions

  • A concession contract that separates transport obligations from speculative land-value revenue
  • Independent feasibility, demand and financial-stress tests before a bundled megaproject is signed
  • A termination and salvage plan that protects the public right-of-way and explains sunk costs

Where else it has been used: Hopewell is now used internationally as a warning against financing core transport with optimistic property capture. The transferable capability is disciplined project preparation and an honest fallback, not a particular rail technology.

Limits: The 14-percent figure is a contemporaneous project-progress estimate in a World Bank case box, not an audited final account of every structure built or every baht spent. Termination records a failed concession and its loss of optionality, not the performance of Bangkok's later rail network. The project combined an elevated road, MRT, railway grade separation and property-development rights, so the failure cannot be assigned to one technical component.