Paraguay
Strongest usable evidence: Adaptability, at 64.8. Raise Experimentation first, at 14.7. Shared purpose needs more evidence: confidence is 0.32.
A solid dot has usable or good evidence and a hollow dot has thin evidence. The tick is the median of the 10 countries nearest in income. A score is a position among the 135 countries, not a percentage.
Raise, lowest first
- ExperimentationPeers 23.00.47 usable-9.1(3)
- LearningPeers 37.30.54 usable-9.2(2)
- AnticipationPeers 41.70.46 usable+19.5(2)
- AgencyPeers 50.40.49 usableno trend
- BuildingPeers 23.80.63 usable+2.0(3)
Measure before managing, thinnest first
- Shared purposePeers 48.30.32 thin+7.7(2)
- TrustPeers 64.00.33 thin+8.6(2)
- CoordinationPeers 69.30.44 thin+9.2(2)
Keep watching, highest first
- AdaptabilityPeers 69.40.62 usable+3.4(4)
These groups are the country's capability agenda, computed from the scores. Read the full agenda. It names comparable evidence from other countries and the 22 gaps in the registry.
Read Paraguay beside up to three other countries, down to the indicator behind every row.
- Usable or good evidence
- Thin evidence, hollow point. The dashes open further as confidence falls.
- The point still sits at the score, because confidence never moves it.
- Click any axis to see every country on that dimension.
A score from 0 to 100 is a position inside the frame that all the benchmark countries set: zero is the weakest on a dimension and 100 is the strongest. A score of 10 puts a country near the floor of that frame and does not mean 10 percent of a capability.
Confidence
- very thin0.00 to 0.25
The score rests on one or two indicators. Do not quote it on its own.
- thin0.25 to 0.45
A minority of indicators, or evidence old enough to have moved. Read with care.
- usable0.45 to 0.65
Enough evidence to compare countries, with known holes.
- good0.65 and above
Most indicators observed, recent, from official or intergovernmental sources.
Why this country is included: Landlocked agro-exporter with a small state and fast recent growth.
Download this country as CSVHow to read this page
Each dimension has a score from 0 to 100. It shows where this country sits among all 135 countries in the comparison frame, not a percentage. Confidence sits beside the score. A dashed radar edge and hollow point mean the evidence is thin. The records below show each indicator, its raw value, year and source.
A panel estimate, when present, is a separate judgment about what the indicators miss. It does not change the score or confidence. The panel's provenance is shown beside the estimate.
A row marked no dataset exists is a gap: the benchmark wants data that nobody publishes. A retired row has a source this project chose not to use. Both reduce confidence. The glossary defines each term, and the limits page lists where these numbers are known to be wrong about the world.
The record behind each score
- direct capability measuredirect capability measure Measures the thing itself.
- capability inputcapability input Measures something that supports the capability.
- downstream outcomedownstream outcome Measures a result that usually follows from the capability.
- perception proxyperception proxy Records what people or experts say, not what they did.
Anticipation
How capable is the country of identifying and preparing for emerging change?
32.70.46 usable2 of 4
Anticipation
How capable is the country of identifying and preparing for emerging change?
Recency 0.96About AnticipationParaguay beside its income peers
Reconstructed history, 2000 to 2026, provisional
- Reconstruction on today's 2 indicators, band 10th to 90th percentile
- Replay on the values that existed each year
- Darker means more indicators modelled
+19.5 over 10 years (2016 to 2026), band +19.5 to +19.5. Median change: all countries +11.2, Latin America +11, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 +12.5.
+19.7 over 20 years (2006 to 2026), band +12.9 to +27.7. Median change: all countries +13.4, Latin America +12.1, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 +15.2.
The model fills at least one of the 2 indicators in 16 of 27 years, at most 1, last in 2015. The replay starts in 2016, the first year with two indicators in force. This never enters a score. How it is built, every country and cohort.
+19.5 over 10 years, from 13.2 in 2016 to 32.7 on 2 indicators seen in both years. Trends use fewer indicators than the current score and use today's frame.
| Indicator | Value | Year | Normalized |
|---|---|---|---|
| downstream outcomeWorld Bank (IP.JRN.ARTC.SC) | 37articles per million peoplefrom 253.35 national total | 2023. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| direct capability measureWorld Bank (IQ.SPI.OVRL) | 74.2index 0-100 | 2024. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. |
No dataset exists for 2 rows, each a gap: Government foresight capacity, Long-horizon research commitments.
Conditions, not scored
What the country has to work with on this capability. The values are shown as the source published them and are not part of the score, the confidence or the trend. The rank counts the countries with a value, best first.
R&D expenditureWorld Bank (GB.XPD.RSDV.GD.ZS), 2023
0.14 % of GDP, rank 100 of 123. Gross domestic expenditure on research and development as a share of GDP.
A condition, not scored: money committed to research is what a country spends, and spending it does not show the country reads the future well.
Researchers in R&DWorld Bank (SP.POP.SCIE.RD.P6), 2023
139 per million people, rank 84 of 118. Full-time-equivalent researchers per million people.
A condition, not scored: a standing stock of people who could investigate is what a country has, not a record of what they found. Correlates with income but survives size normalization.
Secure internet serversWorld Bank (IT.NET.SECR.P6), 2024
775 per million people, rank 71 of 135. Servers using encryption in internet transactions, per million people.
A condition, not scored: a diffusion stock of digital adoption that money buys, not an act of anticipation. Spans four orders of magnitude, so its rank is read on the published value and its correlations on the logged one.
Panel median27.0-5.7 against the indicators
Round 2. How this layer works
- 25.0 institutionalist@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.50
Move from 22 to 25. C's point on macro planning names the fiscal responsibility law, a statutory constraint with a long horizon; very low research output and no foresight body keep me below the derived 32.7.
- 30.0 bottom_up@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.40
Held at 30: panelist A's 22 ignores statistical performance well above income peers; no foresight function keeps it well below the top.
- 27.0 wealth_sceptic@claude-sonnet-5-5, self-confidence 0.40
Moved down 3 to 27: A's point that no foresight function and tiny research output exist is not answered by the 64 statistics score.
Agency
How able are individuals and organizations to turn an intention into action?
35.10.49 usable3 of 5
Agency
How able are individuals and organizations to turn an intention into action?
Recency 0.86About AgencyParaguay beside its income peers
Reconstructed history, 2000 to 2026, provisional
- Reconstruction on today's 3 indicators, band 10th to 90th percentile
- Replay on the values that existed each year
- Darker means more indicators modelled
+3.4 over 10 years (2016 to 2026), band -1.6 to +8.4, which includes no change. Median change: all countries +1.9, Latin America +2.1, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 +2.1.
+21 over 20 years (2006 to 2026), band +15.6 to +26.2. Median change: all countries +9.3, Latin America +9.3, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 +10.6.
The model fills at least one of the 3 indicators in 25 of 27 years, at most 3, last in 2024. The replay starts in 2013, the first year with two indicators in force. This never enters a score. How it is built, every country and cohort.
No trend is shown because too few indicators have values at both ends. The rows below still show the available history.
| Indicator | Value | Year | Normalized |
|---|---|---|---|
| direct capability measureWorld Bank (IC.BUS.NDNS.ZS) | 1.8per 1,000 aged 15-64 | 2024. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| direct capability measureWorld Bank (IC.BRE.BE.P3) | 44.1score 0-100 | 2025. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| direct capability measureWorld Bank (IC.REG.PROC.MA.NO) | 7count | 2019. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. |
No dataset exists for 2 rows, each a gap: Adults doing digital tasks, Perceived control over life.
This project retired one row: Time to start a business.
Conditions, not scored
What the country has to work with on this capability. The values are shown as the source published them and are not part of the score, the confidence or the trend. The rank counts the countries with a value, best first.
Individuals using the internetWorld Bank (IT.NET.USER.ZS), 2024
81.6 % of population, rank 69 of 135. Share of the population that used the internet in the last three months.
A condition, not scored: access to the basic tool of modern agency is what people have to act with, not a record of them acting. Saturates near 95%, which compresses the top of the range.
Financial account ownershipWorld Bank (FX.OWN.TOTL.ZS), 2024
60.9 % aged 15+, rank 80 of 131. Adults with an account at a bank or mobile money provider.
A condition, not scored: holding an account is the precondition for almost any economic action, not the action. Global Findex, published every three years.
Credit to the private sectorWorld Bank (FS.AST.PRVT.GD.ZS), 2025
55.7 % of GDP, rank 48 of 134. Domestic credit provided to the private sector by financial corporations.
A condition, not scored: financial depth is a stock of money available to actors, not what they do with it. High values can also signal a credit bubble, so more is not always better.
Panel median38.0+2.9 against the indicators
Round 2. How this layer works
- 38.0 institutionalist@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.50
Held at 38. Density of 1.761 (10.3), efficiency of 44.05 (26.7) and 7 procedures (68.4) give 35.1. The SAS simplified company law and SUACE (own knowledge) widen entry, so I sit a little above. C agrees at 38. B at 46 cites Mennonite cooperatives, which are durable and which I do credit, but they cover a small population, and Ciudad del Este trade relies on contraband that weak institutions permit.
- 46.0 bottom_up@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.40
Held at 46. Density of 1.761 and entry efficiency of 44.05 give 35.1. Panelists A and C stay at the indicator, and A names the 2020 EAS law as a formal gain only. Ciudad del Este cross-border trade and Mennonite and smallholder cooperatives show action the rows miss (own knowledge). Contraband sits in that trade, and landless campesinos face real limits, so I go no higher.
- 37.0 wealth_sceptic@claude-sonnet-5-5, self-confidence 0.45
I move from 38 to 37. Density 1.761, entry efficiency 44 and 7 procedures give 35.1. Panelist B at 46 cites Ciudad del Este and cooperatives, which the registers miss. Growth rests on soy, beef and hydropower royalties, which is endowment more than conversion, and state delivery is weak. The 2020 simplified-company law widened entry.
Coordination
How effectively can independent actors organize around shared objectives?
49.50.44 thin3 of 5
Coordination
How effectively can independent actors organize around shared objectives?
Recency 0.92About CoordinationParaguay beside its income peers
Reconstructed history, 2000 to 2026, provisional
- Reconstruction on today's 3 indicators, band 10th to 90th percentile
- Replay on the values that existed each year
- Darker means more indicators modelled
+6.1 over 10 years (2016 to 2026), band +1.2 to +10.5. Median change: all countries -1.7, Latin America -1.4, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 +0.5.
-5.3 over 20 years (2006 to 2026), band -9.3 to +0.5, which includes no change. Median change: all countries -2.7, Latin America -5.2, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 -1.8.
The model fills at least one of the 3 indicators in 25 of 27 years, at most 2, last in 2024. The replay starts in 2006, the first year with two indicators in force. This never enters a score. How it is built, every country and cohort.
+9.2 over 10 years, from 52.8 in 2016 to 62.0 on 2 indicators seen in both years. Trends use fewer indicators than the current score and use today's frame.
| Indicator | Value | Year | Normalized |
|---|---|---|---|
| direct capability measureWorld Bank (IC.BRE.IT.P3) | 25.1score 0-100 | 2025. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| direct capability measureWorld Bank (GF.XPD.BUDG.ZS) | 89.9percentage points from approved budget | 2021. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| direct capability measureV-Dem (v2x_cspart) | 0.48index 0-1 | 2025. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. |
No dataset exists for 2 rows, each a gap: University-industry collaboration, Public-private collaboration (1 case below).
This project retired 4 rows: Government effectiveness, Regulatory quality, Logistics performance, Border compliance time to export.
Behavioral check, not scored
Each number below is published beside the score and stays out of it. It is not in the frame, the average, the indicator count or the confidence.
Customs clearance time for exportsWorld Bank (IC.CUS.DURS.EX), 2023
16.373 days, lower is better. Average number of days to clear direct exports through customs, as reported by manufacturing firms that export directly, in the World Bank Enterprise Surveys.
Days a manufacturer that exports directly says its goods took to clear customs, from the World Bank Enterprise Surveys. It is the time the border took on firms' own shipments, current where the Doing Business border time this capability scores is frozen at 2019. It is not scored for two reasons. The number of firms behind each country's figure is published only in the survey microdata, and on a proxy from the published tables 37 of the 53 countries in the frame when it was checked clear 30 exporting firms; Mexico, the Philippines, Israel and nine others may not. And the question changed: surveys fielded from 2024 also ask how long release took across all border agencies, and drop an answer where customs alone took longer, so a country surveyed on both sides of the change can move severalfold with nothing at its border changing. India reads 17.3 days in 2022 and 2.5 in 2025, on more than 9,000 firms each time. No country in the frame has two surveys on the new questionnaire yet. Income is not why it is left out: it barely tracks log GDP per capita.
Evidence for missing indicators
Cases the indicators cannot see. They do not affect the score or confidence, because one case is not comparable across countries.
2017ParaguayRuta PY02 public-private road concessionstill operating
Ruta PY02 public-private road concession
Paraguay's public-works balance records the Ruta PY02 duplication and expansion as a 149.5-kilometre public-private partnership, awarded under the 2013 APP law with a USD 507 million construction contract and a concession running to 2046.
149.5 kilometres, road length under the ruta py02 app contract, 2024. 507,000,000 US dollars, construction contract value, 2017 contract. Paraguay Ministry of Public Works and Communications, 2024 public-management balance, retrieved 2026-08-31.
How it worked: Paraguay used an APP concession to bundle design, financing, construction, maintenance and operation of a national corridor, moving some delivery and lifecycle obligations to a private special-purpose company while the ministry retained contract oversight.
Limits: Contract length and value show the scale and financing model, not whether the road met its promised schedule, lifecycle cost, safety standard or service-level payments. A government project balance can confirm the contract and progress but is not an independent value-for-money review, and construction and operation continue over the concession term.
Panel median45.0-4.5 against the indicators
Round 2. How this layer works
- 43.0 institutionalist@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.40
Revised up one point for B's cooperative point, since Mennonite and other agro-cooperatives are formal organisations that outlast members. A patronage-based civil service and poor trade compliance keep me below B and C.
- 45.0 bottom_up@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.40
Held at 45. Panelist A's patronage point is real for the civil service, but Mennonite and other agricultural cooperatives coordinate production, credit and export at scale, and those are independent actors organising without the state.
- 45.0 wealth_sceptic@claude-sonnet-5-5, self-confidence 0.30
Lowered one point to 45, in line with panelist B. Budget execution is respectable (79/100, 2021) but trade compliance is 25/100 and civil society is middling; cooperatives are a real strength I cannot score.
Trust
How much cooperation is possible beyond immediate personal networks?
49.20.33 thin3 of 7
Trust
How much cooperation is possible beyond immediate personal networks?
Recency 0.97About TrustParaguay beside its income peers
Reconstructed history, 2000 to 2026, provisional
- Reconstruction on today's 3 indicators, band 10th to 90th percentile
- Replay on the values that existed each year
- Darker means more indicators modelled
+1.8 over 10 years (2016 to 2026), band -3.8 to +7.2, which includes no change. Median change: all countries +1.9, Latin America +1.1, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 +1.4.
+5.7 over 20 years (2006 to 2026), band +1.4 to +10.3. Median change: all countries +2.1, Latin America +2, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 +2.
The model fills at least one of the 3 indicators in 25 of 27 years, at most 2, last in 2024. The replay starts in 2006, the first year with two indicators in force. This never enters a score. How it is built, every country and cohort.
+8.6 over 20 years, from 55.2 in 2006 to 63.8 on 2 indicators seen in both years. Trends use fewer indicators than the current score and use today's frame.
| Indicator | Value | Year | Normalized |
|---|---|---|---|
| direct capability measureWorld Bank (IC.BRE.DR.P3) | 38.3score 0-100 | 2025. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| downstream outcomeWorld Bank (IC.FRM.BRIB.ZS) | 16.1% of firms | 2023. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| downstream outcomeV-Dem (v2jucomp_osp) | 2.3scale 0-4 (never to always) | 2025. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. |
No dataset exists for 4 rows, each a gap: Generalised interpersonal trust, Trust in public institutions, Cooperation beyond the in-group, Court case clearance rate.
This project retired 4 rows: Rule of law, Control of corruption, Time to enforce a contract, Intentional homicide rate.
Panel median38.0-11.2 against the indicators
Round 2. How this layer works
- 38.0 institutionalist@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.50
Held at 38. Dispute resolution of 38.275 (20.1), compliance of 2.284 (59.4) and bribery of 16.078% (68.1) give 49.2. All three panelists read Colorado Party influence over courts and prosecutors as the reason to go lower. I add US designations against Horacio Cartes, later lifted, and the 2024 expulsion of a senator (own knowledge). The narrow range reflects shared own knowledge, which I flag, and B's mingas and coops remain near home.
- 39.0 bottom_up@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.45
Held at 39. Bribery of 16.078%, compliance of 2.284 and dispute resolution of 38.275 give 49.2. All panelists go lower for the Colorado hold on courts and prosecutors, and the 36 to 39 range is narrow. I keep the top of it because cooperatives and mingas extend somewhat beyond family (own knowledge), though mostly close to home.
- 36.0 wealth_sceptic@claude-sonnet-5-5, self-confidence 0.50
I hold 36. Dispute resolution 38 (20), compliance 2.28 (59.4) and bribery 16% (68) give 49.2, which is high. Single-party dominance by the Colorado Party for most of the last 70 years, a captured prosecutor's office and narco-linked assassinations weaken institutional trust. Panelists A and B at 38 and 39 land close.
Learning
How effectively does the country acquire, distribute, and update knowledge?
31.80.54 usable3 of 4
Learning
How effectively does the country acquire, distribute, and update knowledge?
Recency 0.78About LearningParaguay beside its income peers
Reconstructed history, 2000 to 2026, provisional
- Reconstruction on today's 3 indicators, band 10th to 90th percentile
- Replay on the values that existed each year
- Darker means more indicators modelled
-4 over 10 years (2016 to 2026), band -6.8 to -1. Median change: all countries -1.3, Latin America -3.5, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 -1.6.
-5.1 over 20 years (2006 to 2026), band -9.5 to +0.7, which includes no change. Median change: all countries +0.8, Latin America +2.2, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 -0.3.
The model fills at least one of the 3 indicators in 10 of 27 years, at most 3, last in 2009. The replay starts in 2006, the first year with two indicators in force. This never enters a score. How it is built, every country and cohort.
-9.2 over 20 years, from 36.8 in 2006 to 27.6 on 2 indicators seen in both years. Trends use fewer indicators than the current score and use today's frame.
| Indicator | Value | Year | Normalized |
|---|---|---|---|
| direct capability measureWorld Bank (HD.HCI.OVRL) | 0.53index 0-1 | 2020. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| direct capability measureWorld Bank (IC.FRM.TRNG.ZS) | 36.5% of firms | 2023. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| downstream outcomeOpenAlex (citation_normalized_percentile.is_in_top_10_percent) | 0.38ratio to world average | 2021. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. |
No dataset exists for one row, each a gap: Adult learning participation (1 case below).
Conditions, not scored
What the country has to work with on this capability. The values are shown as the source published them and are not part of the score, the confidence or the trend. The rank counts the countries with a value, best first.
Tertiary enrolmentWorld Bank (SE.TER.ENRR), 2010
37.6 % gross, rank 78 of 134. Gross enrolment ratio in tertiary education.
The value is from 2010, more than 15 years old.
A condition, not scored: enrolment counts people in formal education and records nothing learned.
Public education expenditureWorld Bank (SE.XPD.TOTL.GD.ZS), 2024
3.5 % of GDP, rank 85 of 135. Government expenditure on education as a share of GDP.
A condition, not scored: public spending on education is a pure input, and learning is what the dimension asks about.
Vocational share of secondaryWorld Bank (SE.SEC.ENRL.VO.ZS), 2016
15.9 % of secondary, rank 49 of 135. Vocational pupils as a share of total secondary enrolment.
A condition, not scored: the share of secondary pupils on a vocational track describes how a school system is built, not what anyone learns in it, and higher is not unambiguously better. It marks a route into skilled work that does not run through university. Learning reads research citation impact, firm training and the human capital index instead.
Evidence for missing indicators
Cases the indicators cannot see. They do not affect the score or confidence, because one case is not comparable across countries.
1998ParaguayEducación Permanente para personas jóvenes y adultas (MEC)still operating
Educación Permanente para personas jóvenes y adultas (MEC)
Paraguay's Ministry of Education and Sciences enrolled 94,436 young people and adults in its four formal and non-formal Educación Permanente programmes in 2025, as reported in the Ministry of Economy and Finance's budget evaluation for that year.
94,436 students, students enrolled in the four formal and non-formal educación permanente programmes for young people and adults, 2025. Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas del Paraguay, Informe Financiero 2025, Tomo II: Control Financiero y Evaluación Presupuestaria (MEC section), retrieved 2026-10-02.
How it worked: The education ministry runs basic, secondary and vocational second-chance programmes for over-age learners through a national network of centres, many hosted in ordinary schools in the evening, and reports enrolment through the budget-by-results system.
Limits: The number sits in one sentence on printed page 34 (PDF page 35) of a budget evaluation, sourced in its footnote to the education ministry's own reporting (SIME N° 5.130/2026); the ministry is reporting on itself through the finance ministry. The programmes serve people aged 15 and over, so part of the count is youth rather than adults, and enrolment is not completion. 94,436 is about 2 percent of Paraguay's adult population, so this evidences a standing national second-chance system, not broad adult participation. The four programmes are not broken out, and no earlier year is given on this page, so no trend can be read; the education ministry's open-data portal, which carries the enrolment series, did not respond from here. The started year is the 1998 General Education Law that set out permanent education for young people and adults; it is not stated in the source.
Panel median30.0-1.8 against the indicators
Round 2. How this layer works
- 30.0 institutionalist@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.50
Held. HCI and citation impact are low and firm training is the only bright spot; the panel agrees.
- 32.0 bottom_up@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.45
Held at 32. The panel agrees within three points; firm training at 44/100 is the one bright spot and it does not offset low HCI and thin research output.
- 30.0 wealth_sceptic@claude-sonnet-5-5, self-confidence 0.35
Raised one point to 30. HCI 0.53 and citation impact 11/100 are low; firm training at 44/100 is a bright spot but one item, and nobody on the panel disagrees by more than 2 points.
Experimentation
How easily can new approaches be attempted, tested, abandoned, and improved?
14.70.47 usable5 of 10
Experimentation
How easily can new approaches be attempted, tested, abandoned, and improved?
Recency 1.00About ExperimentationParaguay beside its income peers
Reconstructed history, 2000 to 2026, provisional
- Reconstruction on today's 5 indicators, band 10th to 90th percentile
- Replay on the values that existed each year
- Darker means more indicators modelled
-2.7 over 10 years (2016 to 2026), band -6.9 to +2, which includes no change. Median change: all countries 0, Latin America +0.5, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 0.
-5.4 over 20 years (2006 to 2026), band -9.3 to -1.9. Median change: all countries +0.1, Latin America +0.5, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 +0.8.
The model fills at least one of the 5 indicators in 26 of 27 years, at most 3, last in 2025. The replay starts in 2000, the first year with two indicators in force. This never enters a score. How it is built, every country and cohort.
-9.1 over 20 years, from 22.4 in 2006 to 13.3 on 3 indicators seen in both years. Trends use fewer indicators than the current score and use today's frame.
| Indicator | Value | Year | Normalized |
|---|---|---|---|
| downstream outcomeWorld Bank (IP.PAT.RESD) | 2.2per million peoplefrom 15 national total | 2024. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| downstream outcomeWorld Bank (IP.TMK.RSCT) | 1,930per million peoplefrom 13,376 national total | 2024. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| downstream outcomeWorld Bank (IP.IDS.RSCT) | 2.3per million peoplefrom 16 national total | 2024. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| downstream outcomeGitHub Innovation Graph (data/repositories.csv) | 5,278per million peoplefrom 37,017 national total | 2026. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| Early-stage entrepreneurial activitydirect capability measureGlobal Entrepreneurship Monitor (APS key indicators, TEA rate) | no data% aged 18-64 | no data | no data |
| Tolerance of entrepreneurial failureperception proxyGlobal Entrepreneurship Monitor (APS key indicators, fear of failure rate) | no data% not deterred | no data | no data |
| direct capability measureWorld Bank (IC.BRE.BI.P3) | 23.8score 0-100 | 2025. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. |
No dataset exists for 3 rows, each a gap: Venture deals, Firms through regulatory sandboxes, University spinouts.
This project retired one row: Business share of R&D.
Panel median14.0-0.7 against the indicators
Round 2. How this layer works
- 12.0 institutionalist@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.55
Hold at 12. B's cross-border trade is informal and partly contraband, not trial a legal order protects; insolvency at 24.1 is weak.
- 16.0 bottom_up@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.35
Held at 16: panelist C ties trademarks to import trade, which is still trial; a large informal and cross-border trade economy at Ciudad del Este adds unmeasured experimentation.
- 14.0 wealth_sceptic@claude-sonnet-5-5, self-confidence 0.40
Moved down 1 to 14: A (12) and B (16) agree; I read trademark scores as commodity-trade-linked and insolvency efficiency of 24.1 is weak.
Adaptability
How effectively can the system respond when circumstances change?
64.80.62 usable4 of 6
Adaptability
How effectively can the system respond when circumstances change?
Recency 1.00About AdaptabilityParaguay beside its income peers
Reconstructed history, 2000 to 2026, provisional
- Reconstruction on today's 4 indicators, band 10th to 90th percentile
- Replay on the values that existed each year
- Darker means more indicators modelled
+3.4 over 10 years (2016 to 2026), band +3.4 to +3.4. Median change: all countries -0.8, Latin America -1.7, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 +0.8.
+9.7 over 20 years (2006 to 2026), band +5.2 to +14.1. Median change: all countries -1, Latin America -4, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 -1.5.
The model fills at least one of the 4 indicators in 10 of 27 years, at most 2, last in 2009. The replay starts in 2000, the first year with two indicators in force. This never enters a score. How it is built, every country and cohort.
+3.4 over 10 years, from 61.4 in 2016 to 64.8 on 4 indicators seen in both years. Trends use fewer indicators than the current score and use today's frame.
| Indicator | Value | Year | Normalized |
|---|---|---|---|
| downstream outcomeWorld Bank (SL.UEM.TOTL.ZS) | 4.8% of labour force | 2025. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| downstream outcomeILOSTAT (DF_UNE_TUNE_SEX_AGE_DUR_NB) | 23.3% of unemployed | 2025. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| direct capability measureUNCTAD (US.ConcentDiversIndices) | 0.26index 0-1, lower = more diversified | 2025. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| downstream outcomeHarvard Growth Lab (hs92_country_product_year_4.csv (doi:10.7910/DVN/T4CHWJ)) | 2.3% of products not exported competitively at the start | 2024. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. |
No dataset exists for 2 rows, each a gap: Disaster preparedness and recovery (1 case below), Institutional responsiveness (2 cases below).
Conditions, not scored
What the country has to work with on this capability. The values are shown as the source published them and are not part of the score, the confidence or the trend. The rank counts the countries with a value, best first.
Labour force participationWorld Bank (SL.TLF.ACTI.ZS), 2025
73.9 % aged 15+, rank 51 of 135. Share of the working-age population in the labour force.
A condition, not scored: how much of the population is in the labor force at all is what a country has to reallocate, a level set by norms, schooling and age, not a record of it reallocating. Participation norms confound it, especially for India. Adaptability reads reallocation through long-term unemployment and export diversification instead.
Fixed broadband subscriptionsWorld Bank (IT.NET.BBND.P2), 2023
12.9 per 100 people, rank 72 of 135. Fixed broadband subscriptions per 100 people.
A condition, not scored: installed infrastructure is what a country has to change with, not a record of it changing. Penalizes mobile-first countries such as India and South Africa.
Electricity transmission lossesWorld Bank (EG.ELC.LOSS.ZS), 2024
16.3 % of output, rank 94 of 122. Power lost in transmission and distribution, including unbilled use.
A condition, not scored: the state of the grid, and whether its operator can bill what it delivers, is infrastructure a country has to change with, not a record of it changing. Read it beside broadband, the other installed network beside Adaptability.
Informal employmentILOSTAT (DF_SDG_0831_SEX_ECO_RT), 2025
64.5 % of employment, rank 61 of 111. Informal employment as a share of total employment, SDG indicator 8.3.1.
A condition, not scored: how much work carries no contract, registration or social protection describes the labor market a country reallocates through, not it reallocating. Read it beside the unemployment rate: where most work is informal, a person who loses a job takes any work within weeks, so a low rate is not a fluid market. Its direction for Adaptability cannot be defended, since informal work is both the slack that absorbs a shock and the precarity that keeps a worker from moving up, so the rank orders values and is not a verdict. Comparability is weak: the European values come from an income survey (EU-SILC) with a proxy definition, and the rest from labor force or household surveys processed by the ILO. ILOSTAT has no value for the United States, Canada, Australia, Japan, Singapore, Israel, Malaysia, China, the Philippines or Cuba, and some values are old (Haiti and Nicaragua 2012).
Evidence for missing indicators
Cases the indicators cannot see. They do not affect the score or confidence, because one case is not comparable across countries.
2005ParaguayTekoporã Mbarete family-support programmestill operating
Tekoporã Mbarete family-support programme
Paraguay's Tekoporã Mbarete social-protection programme protected more than 175,000 families nationwide in 2024, paid monthly after a 2023 redesign and reported 95% bankarisation plus georeferencing of 11,316 participating homes.
175,000 families, families protected by tekoporã mbarete, 2024. 95 % of families, participating families with a bank payment channel, 2024. Government of Paraguay, Presidential Management Report 2024, retrieved 2026-08-31.
How it worked: Paraguay combined a recurring transfer with family guides, monthly payment and a georeferenced beneficiary register, then pushed bank access into a programme that had previously paid less frequently and reached families unevenly.
Limits: Family coverage and payment-channel penetration show administrative reach, not whether transfers arrive on time, meet household needs or improve health, schooling and income. The report is the government's own account and does not provide a counterfactual impact estimate; georeferencing also cannot by itself reveal who remains excluded from the registry.
2021ParaguaySIFEN national electronic invoicing rolloutstill operating
SIFEN national electronic invoicing rollout
Paraguay's tax administration approved 651,894,711 electronic tax documents during 2024 and reported 6,659 electronic billers using the SIFEN system, combining mandatory onboarding for larger firms with the free e-Kuatia'i route for small taxpayers.
651,894,711 documents, electronic tax documents approved, 2024. 6,659 taxpayers, electronic billers registered, 2024-12. Paraguay National Directorate of Tax Revenues, 2024 public management balance, retrieved 2026-08-31.
How it worked: Paraguay made the tax document a machine-readable event: SIFEN set a national standard, validated documents centrally and combined a mandatory calendar for larger taxpayers with a free tool and electronic signature path for smaller ones.
Limits: Document and taxpayer counts show system throughput and adoption, not the revenue effect, compliance cost, uptime or whether informal firms can participate without disproportionate burden. The tax authority reports the implementation totals, and the staged mandate means the 2024 base was not yet a census of all taxpayers.
2019ParaguaySecretaría de Emergencia Nacional response to the 2019 floodsdelivered and closed
Secretaría de Emergencia Nacional response to the 2019 floods
By 29 May 2019, Paraguay's Secretaría de Emergencia Nacional had assisted 62,521 of the 65,000 families affected by the flash floods of March to May 2019 across 14 departments, delivering 1.5 million kg of food, 150,000 roofing sheets and 110,000 plywood boards.
62,521 families, of 65,000 affected, flood-affected families assisted, 2019-05-29. Government of Paraguay (Secretaría de Emergencia Nacional) press release, republished by ReliefWeb (UN OCHA), retrieved 2026-10-02.
How it worked: The national emergency secretariat, holding its own emergency fund, procured food and building materials centrally and distributed them department by department against a household count, with shelters in Asunción run alongside civil-society groups.
Limits: Both the numerator and the 65,000 denominator are the government's own counts, published by the agency that did the work, and nobody independent checked them; the text is read on ReliefWeb's republication because sen.gov.py did not answer a scripted request today. Assistance is relief in kind (food, props, sheets and boards for self-repair), not reconstruction, resettlement or risk reduction, and the release gives no timing, so it cannot show how fast families were reached. Some assistance in the Chaco was delivered with the First Lady's office. Repeated flooding of the same Asunción riverside settlements shows the relief cycle does not reduce exposure.
Panel median52.0-12.8 against the indicators
Round 2. How this layer works
- 51.0 institutionalist@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.40
Revised up one point. C and I agree that low unemployment in an informal economy says little about reallocation, and new export products are weak; B's 58 gives too much weight to outcome measures.
- 58.0 bottom_up@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.40
Held at 58. Panelists A and C at 50 make the same point I did, that low unemployment in an informal economy shows absorption more than reallocation, but they then cut further for commodity dependence that diversification at 74/100 does not show.
- 52.0 wealth_sceptic@claude-sonnet-5-5, self-confidence 0.30
Held near 50, now 52. Unemployment (80/100) in an informal economy reads absorption into low-productivity work; new export products are 26/100 and the base is soy, beef and hydro. Panelist B's 58 and my 52 both accept this point; I stay lower.
Building
How capable is the country of turning plans and knowledge into functioning systems?
36.70.63 usable4 of 6
Building
How capable is the country of turning plans and knowledge into functioning systems?
Recency 1.00About BuildingParaguay beside its income peers
Reconstructed history, 2000 to 2026, provisional
- Reconstruction on today's 4 indicators, band 10th to 90th percentile
- Replay on the values that existed each year
- Darker means more indicators modelled
+1.5 over 10 years (2016 to 2026), band -2.3 to +5.3, which includes no change. Median change: all countries -0.3, Latin America -1.2, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 -0.3.
+2.4 over 20 years (2006 to 2026), band -1.6 to +7.2, which includes no change. Median change: all countries -0.5, Latin America -2.6, Income quartile 3 of 4 in 2000 -0.8.
The model fills at least one of the 4 indicators in 25 of 27 years, at most 3, last in 2024. The replay starts in 2007, the first year with two indicators in force. This never enters a score. How it is built, every country and cohort.
+2.0 over 10 years, from 23.0 in 2016 to 25.0 on 3 indicators seen in both years. Trends use fewer indicators than the current score and use today's frame.
| Indicator | Value | Year | Normalized |
|---|---|---|---|
| downstream outcomeWorld Bank (NV.IND.MANF.ZS) | 19.4% of GDP | 2025. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| downstream outcomeWorld Bank (TX.VAL.TECH.MF.ZS) | 10.5% of manufactured exports | 2024. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| direct capability measureWorld Bank (IC.BRE.US.P3) | 77.8score 0-100 | 2025. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. | |
| downstream outcomeWorld Bank (EF.EFM.UNIV.XD) | 0.07index | 2024. The rail runs from 1960 to 2026. |
No dataset exists for 2 rows, each a gap: Large project delivery (3 cases below), Firm scale-up rate.
This project retired 2 rows: Logistics infrastructure quality, Electricity connection speed.
Conditions, not scored
What the country has to work with on this capability. The values are shown as the source published them and are not part of the score, the confidence or the trend. The rank counts the countries with a value, best first.
Output per workerWorld Bank (SL.GDP.PCAP.EM.KD), 2025
36,004 constant 2021 PPP $, rank 75 of 133. GDP per person employed, constant purchasing power parity.
A condition, not scored: output per worker is income per worker, the wealth the benchmark tests capability against, so it is published beside Building as context.
Evidence for missing indicators
Cases the indicators cannot see. They do not affect the score or confidence, because one case is not comparable across countries.
1984ParaguayItaipú binational hydropower operationsstill operating
Itaipú binational hydropower operations
Itaipú supplied Paraguay's grid with 20,383 GWh in 2024, 4.5% more than in 2023, while the binational plant generated 67,089 GWh in total and continued operating after four decades of service.
20,383 GWh, energy supplied to paraguay, 2024. 67,089 GWh, total itaipú generation, 2024. Itaipú Binacional, 2024 production and supply report, retrieved 2026-08-31.
How it worked: Paraguay sustained a technically complex binational asset through a permanent operating institution, shared dispatch and long-horizon maintenance rather than treating the dam as finished when construction ended; the national grid could then convert a cross-border project into domestic energy security.
Limits: Annual generation and supply show output from an operating asset, not the original cost and schedule, transmission reliability, environmental effects or the distributional consequences of the binational tariff and power-allocation rules. Hydrology strongly affects the yearly number, and the plant's own report is not an independent project audit.
2015ParaguayMetrobús, an unfinished bus rapid transit projectdismantled
Metrobús, an unfinished bus rapid transit project
Paraguay's planned Asunción Metrobús corridor ended with an incomplete and unviable works package: in April 2024 the Public Prosecutor's Office said the state had paid certificates for works that did not meet the programme's purpose and alleged a G.180.03 billion patrimonial loss.
180,030,528,699 Paraguayan guaranies, patrimonial harm alleged in the metrobús prosecution, 2024-04. Paraguay Public Prosecutor's Office, Metrobús prosecution notice, retrieved 2026-08-31.
How it worked: Paraguay attempted a multi-municipality bus rapid transit corridor through a public works contract, but weak design integration, contract management and escalation left paid works disconnected from a functioning service and triggered an ex-post prosecution rather than an operating system.
Limits: The loss figure is an allegation in an ongoing criminal case, not a final judicial finding or a complete cost-benefit account. The notice establishes that the works were incomplete and did not serve the stated programme, but it does not measure the corridor's intended passenger benefits, the full financing cost or the later value of infrastructure retained by the state.
2020ParaguayPuente Héroes del Chaco, Asunción to Chaco'i bridgedelivered and closed
Puente Héroes del Chaco, Asunción to Chaco'i bridge
Paraguay's Ministry of Public Works began building the Héroes del Chaco cable-stayed bridge, the first road link from Asunción to the Chaco, in 2020 on an estimated 36-month schedule; at the end of 2023 it reported 90% physical progress against 100% planned, and the bridge was inaugurated on 3 March 2024 and recorded as concluded with provisional acceptance in the 2024 balance.
90 % physical progress, physical progress against plan at year end (planned 100%), 2023-12. 36 months, estimated execution period, 2021 balance. Paraguay Ministry of Public Works and Communications (MOPC), Balance Anual de Gestión Pública 2023, retrieved 2026-10-01.
How it worked: MOPC tendered the bridge through national public tender MOPC No 156/2019, awarded it to Consorcio Union, financed it from the general budget, and tracked planned against physical progress each year in its public balance.
Limits: All figures are the ministry's own reports; no audit-office or independent value-for-money review was opened. The schedule figure is a progress-against-plan percentage in a year-end table, which says the works were behind their own plan at end-2023 but not by how many months; the official sources opened give the construction start only as a year, so a month-precise overrun cannot be computed (a 2020 start plus 36 months gives completion within 2023, against an inauguration on 3 March 2024, i.e. at least two months late, and the 2021 balance showed the works ahead of plan, 43.25% against 32.30%). No total contract cost, original award value or cost overrun appears in the balances opened: the 2024 table carries only that year's spending (G. 98,099,704,513). Press reports describing the bridge as delayed and more expensive were leads only and are not the source.
Panel median34.0-2.7 against the indicators
Round 2. How this layer works
- 33.0 institutionalist@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.45
Revised up one point. B and C are right that Itaipú is inherited binational capacity, not current delivery, so I drop it as support; utility connections and manufacturing share keep me near the indicator.
- 35.0 bottom_up@claude-opus-5-5, self-confidence 0.40
Held at 35. Panelist C and I agree that Itaipú is an inherited asset rather than current delivery; utility connection at 72/100 is a working process and economic fitness near the floor caps it.
- 34.0 wealth_sceptic@claude-sonnet-5-5, self-confidence 0.30
Lowered one point to 34. Economic fitness is 2/100; Itaipu is binational endowment, as panelist B says. Utility connection (72/100) and manufacturing at 55/100 hold it above the floor.