Skip to content
NCBNational Capability Benchmark
Navigate with โ†‘ โ†“Enter to openEsc to close

Challenge the benchmark

Choose a score and give the benchmark a specific reason to reconsider it.

When you submit, the form attaches the current score and confidence for the country and capability you chose.

Submissions are public and start as awaiting review. A maintainer can add a response and signature after review.

Documented examples

Each record describes something a country built that the indicators do not capture. The source provides the published number; the mechanism is our interpretation.

Scores describe outcomes. These records describe how a country acted, what it needed and what happened. 742 of 742 records include a mechanism. They do not affect scores.

Narrow the list

8 of 742 deliveries

Coordination

1 delivery linked to Public-private collaboration.

Costa Ricasince 1997still operatingbears on Public-private collaboration

FONAFIFO Payment for Environmental Services

Costa Rica's FONAFIFO Payment for Environmental Services programme paid contracts covering 208,089 hectares in 2024, disbursing โ‚ก9.234 billion while using public, donor and market-linked finance to keep private land in forest uses.

208,089 hectares, hectares under payment for environmental services contracts, 2024. 9,234,000,000 Costa Rican colones, payments disbursed through the programme, 2024. FONAFIFO, Board meeting record and 2024 programme accounts, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

Costa Rica created a dedicated forest-finance institution that collects earmarked public revenue and combines it with donor and market funds, then pays landowners under monitored contracts for water, carbon and biodiversity services.

Preconditions

  • A legal mandate and predictable revenue stream that can fund multi-year land contracts
  • Land records, spatial targeting and field monitoring able to verify who is paid for what
  • A public institution trusted by landowners and external funders to administer contracts and report results

Where else it has been used: Payments for ecosystem services travel well as a way to make stewardship financially visible, but Costa Rica's case shows the hard part: stable public finance and credible monitoring must survive changes in carbon markets and land prices.

Limits: Contract hectares and payments show the reach of a conservation-finance mechanism, not whether forest cover is additional, permanent or evenly distributed. The board record is an administrative account from the programme operator; it does not independently verify carbon permanence, biodiversity outcomes or the counterfactual land use.

Learning

1 delivery linked to Adult learning participation.

Costa Ricasince 1965operating below its peakbears on Adult learning participation

INA national vocational training, and its contraction

Costa Rica's Instituto Nacional de Aprendizaje (INA) recorded 204,773 training enrolments in 2024, down from 313,276 in 2015 at the high point of its 2010 to 2019 plateau, a fall of about 35 percent that the 2020 to 2024 recovery did not reverse.

204,773 enrolments, ina total enrolments (gestiรณn total matrรญculas), current, 2024. 313,276 enrolments, ina total enrolments at the high point of the 2010 to 2019 plateau, 2015. Instituto Nacional de Aprendizaje (INA), Unidad de Planificaciรณn y Evaluaciรณn, INA en Cifras 2024, Cuadro 8.1, retrieved 2026-10-01.

The move, and what it needed

Costa Rica built a single national training institute in 1965 and financed it largely from an employer payroll contribution, so INA could run free courses across every region without competing for annual budget allocations; after 2019 its enrolments fell back to roughly the level of the mid-2000s.

Preconditions

  • A dedicated, earmarked revenue stream that does not depend on yearly appropriations
  • A regional network of training centres able to reach rural planning regions as well as the Central Valley
  • A curriculum and certification model that employers recognise, which INA has been redesigning around competencies

Where else it has been used: The payroll-levy training institute is a Latin American family (SENA in Colombia, SENAI in Brazil, INA in Costa Rica). Costa Rica's series shows that the protected revenue keeps the institution alive but does not by itself keep participation from contracting when delivery models change.

Limits: Enrolments are a count of course registrations at one provider, not the share of adults in education or training that the gap asks for: a person can enrol more than once, and INA counted 97,870 distinct participants in 2024, roughly 2 to 3 percent of the adult population on our own rough arithmetic, with private, university, employer and online training invisible here. The table is INA reporting on itself and is not independently audited. The series is not clearly comparable across the break: the 2020 to 2024 tables state that enrolments cover programme modules, certifiable modules, technical assistance and competency certification, and the same yearbook reports enrolments in services run by accredited outside entities separately (87,258 in 2023, 65,300 in 2024), so part of the fall may be reclassification rather than lost reach; the yearbook does not reconcile the definitions. The single highest year is 2009 at 382,786, an isolated spike, so the peak named here is the 2015 plateau high and the fall would read as about 47 percent against 2009. The steepest drop (266,679 in 2019 to 172,664 in 2020) is the pandemic year, but the decline had begun in 2019 and enrolments stayed near 205,000 to 212,000 from 2022 to 2024. The number says nothing about training quality, completion or job outcomes, and the PDF has to be opened and read off a table.

Adaptability

4 deliveries linked to Institutional responsiveness, Export diversification, Disaster preparedness and recovery.

Costa Ricasince 2005still operatingbears on Institutional responsiveness

Certified digital signature across public services

Costa Rica's MICITT reported in October 2023 that more than 60 public institutions used certified digital signatures across more than 100 citizen services, with almost 75,000 certificates issued during that year.

100 services, public services using certified digital signature, 2023-10. 75,000 certificates, digital certificates issued during the year, 2023. Ministry of Science, Innovation, Technology and Telecommunications (MICITT), certified digital signature update, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

Costa Rica combined a law granting electronic documents legal force with a national certification hierarchy, MICITT oversight and Banco Central support, then let agencies reuse the credential for signatures and online procedures instead of inventing separate trust systems.

Preconditions

  • A legal framework that makes a digital signature equivalent to a handwritten one
  • A certificate authority and identity-enrolment process that citizens and institutions can access
  • A central coordinator able to publish standards and help agencies migrate real procedures

Where else it has been used: Digital-signature systems travel more easily than full digital government because they start with a legal trust decision. Costa Rica shows that certificates become useful only when agencies convert them into complete services rather than a token login.

Limits: Institution and service counts show adoption of a legal and technical rail, not completion rates, user equity, fraud resistance or savings. Certificates issued are not the same as active users, and the adoption figures are reported by the coordinating ministry rather than independently audited across agencies.

Costa Ricasince 2010still operatingbears on Institutional responsiveness

REDCUDI childcare network and SINIRUBE referrals

Costa Rica's IMAS reported that its national Childcare and Early Development benefit reached 25,704 children in 2024 with an investment of โ‚ก13.2 billion, while interinstitutional referrals used SINIRUBE to match eligible families to available places.

25,704 children, children receiving the childcare and development benefit, 2024. 13,200,000,000 Costa Rican colones, social investment in the benefit, 2024. Instituto Mixto de Ayuda Social (IMAS), national childcare and social-programme report, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

Costa Rica linked IMAS, PANI, CEN-CINAI, local authorities and private providers through the REDCUDI network, using the SINIRUBE social registry to refer eligible families into available childcare capacity rather than asking each institution to target alone.

Preconditions

  • A shared beneficiary registry with rules for privacy, eligibility and referral
  • Multiple public and private providers that can accept common standards and funding
  • A financing mechanism able to sustain places across agencies and localities

Where else it has been used: Integrated childcare networks travel as a coordination problem, not just a subsidy. Costa Rica's model highlights the registry and referral layer that lets scarce places move toward eligible families while leaving delivery plural.

Limits: Beneficiary and spending totals show administrative reach, not child development, quality, waiting lists or whether the service enables parents to work. The programme combines several providers and modalities, so the national total can hide very different experiences and does not independently audit outcomes.

Costa Ricasince 2021still operatingbears on Export diversification

Ramp Up, PROCOMER's export-readiness programme

Costa Rica's export agency PROCOMER reported that 40 SMEs graduated from its 16-week Ramp Up 2024 programme, delivered with INA and the Sistema de Banca para el Desarrollo, bringing the number of firms benefiting since the programme began in 2021 to 175.

40 SMEs, smes graduating from ramp up 2024, 2025-02-26. 175 SMEs, smes benefiting since launch, 2025-02-26. PROCOMER, Ramp Up 2024 export-capability programme, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

PROCOMER, the national training institute and a development bank combine practical training in finance, strategy, governance and sustainability with export-market connections. The package builds the organisational routines and compliance readiness that small firms need before an overseas buyer or distributor can become repeat business.

Preconditions

  • An export agency that can identify firms, broker market access and coordinate services rather than offering disconnected workshops
  • SMEs with a product, management time and enough operational capacity to act on finance, quality and sustainability work
  • Training, development finance and buyer or standards networks that remain available after graduation

Where else it has been used: Export-readiness programmes travel when capability-building is tied to real market links and finance; a course certificate without buyer validation, working capital or standards support rarely diversifies exports by itself.

Limits: Graduation and reach counts show programme delivery, not verified export growth, new markets, product diversification, export survival or causal impact. PROCOMER describes the firms as strengthening export capability; the source does not establish that all graduates exported or that the programme changed Costa Rica's aggregate concentration.

Costa Ricasince 2017delivered and closedbears on Disaster preparedness and recovery

Hurricane Otto priority reconstruction works

In the 17 months to September 2018, the Instituto Costarricense de Electricidad, under an agreement with the national emergency commission (CNE), completed 64 of the 65 priority reconstruction works after Hurricane Otto of November 2016, rebuilding 20 bridges and 211 km of rural roads for โ‚ก18,500 million.

64 works, of 65 programmed, priority reconstruction works concluded, 2018-09-12. 18,500 โ‚ก million, investment in the priority works, 2018-09-12. Government of Costa Rica, Presidencia de la Repรบblica press release, republished by ReliefWeb (UN OCHA), retrieved 2026-10-02.

The move, and what it needed

The CNE, which holds the national emergency fund and the declared emergency plan, contracted the state electricity and telecom utility as a single builder for the priority works instead of tendering each bridge, and coordinated it with the public works ministry and five municipalities.

Preconditions

  • A standing emergency fund and a legal emergency declaration that unlocks direct contracting
  • A state enterprise with engineering crews and plant spread across the country
  • A short, costed list of priority works agreed in the emergency plan

Where else it has been used: Using a state utility as the reconstruction contractor recurs in Costa Rica's later emergencies; it travels only where such a utility exists and is trusted, and it concentrates risk if that enterprise is overstretched.

Limits: The source is the government's own completion announcement; the original presidencia.go.cr page now returns 404 and the text survives in ReliefWeb's republication, which names the Government of Costa Rica as source. Completion is measured against the government's own list of 65 priority works, not against total damage: the same government estimated recovery needs at about โ‚ก130,000 million, so โ‚ก18,500 million is a fraction of the recovery and the record shows the priority tranche only. The started year is computed from the release's '17 months' and is not stated directly. The remaining work, a bridge over the Zapote river, was delayed by expropriation. Nothing here shows whether the rebuilt bridges and roads were built to a higher standard or maintained; the Contralorรญa has reported maintenance gaps on emergency-fund projects, but its document server refused connections today and that finding is not relied on.

Building

2 deliveries linked to Large project delivery.

Costa Ricasince 1949still operatingbears on Large project delivery

ICE and a mostly renewable national electricity system

Costa Rica's integrated electricity system generated 89.4% of its electricity from renewable sources in 2024, while ICE reported electrical coverage reaching 98.7% of households despite one of the country's driest years on record.

89.4 % of generation, renewable share of electricity generation, 2024. 98.7 % of households, households with electricity coverage, 2024. Instituto Costarricense de Electricidad, 2024 renewable-generation report, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

A state utility planned generation and controlled the transmission backbone, combining public hydro and geothermal investment with regulated contracts for private and cooperative wind, solar and biomass while extending the distribution grid to remote households.

Preconditions

  • A technically capable utility with authority to plan generation and operate the national grid
  • Long-horizon finance and resource mapping for projects whose benefits arrive over decades
  • A regulatory framework that lets private and cooperative generators sell into a coordinated system

Where else it has been used: Renewable-grid programmes travel as portfolios rather than single projects. Costa Rica's experience makes the enabling bundle visible: a transmission spine, credible offtake and a utility that can coordinate public, private and cooperative assets.

Limits: The renewable share and household coverage are outcomes, not a project-by-project cost or schedule record. Hydrology, imports and thermal backup move the annual mix, and the utility report does not independently audit the full lifetime cost, reliability or distributional effects of the generation portfolio.

Costa Ricasince 1941still operatingbears on Large project delivery

CCSS universal health-insurance reach

Costa Rica's Caja Costarricense de Seguro Social reported health-insurance coverage of 92.92% of the national population in 2024, using household-survey and administrative records to include contributors, dependents, pensioners and state-covered households.

92.92 % of population, population covered by the ccss health insurance, 2024. 360,124 people, population recorded as uninsured, 2024. Caja Costarricense de Seguro Social, Institutional Memory 2024, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

Costa Rica expanded a contributory social-insurance institution into a near-universal insurer-provider by covering dependents, pensioners and state-financed households through a common pool and an integrated primary-care network.

Preconditions

  • A statutory social-insurance body with authority to collect contributions and contract or operate care
  • A broad payroll base and public subsidy for households outside formal employment
  • A nationwide clinic and referral network that turns insurance status into a service

Where else it has been used: Universal-insurance models travel only when the financing and delivery institutions travel together. Costa Rica's coverage figure is a reminder that the hard capability is not declaring a right but maintaining the pool, clinics and cross-subsidy that make it real.

Limits: Insurance coverage is not the same as timely access, quality, financial protection or equal outcomes, and the estimate comes from a combination of survey and administrative data. It also does not show the operating cost or schedule of the facilities and workforce that make a legal entitlement usable.