Skip to content
NCBNational Capability Benchmark
Navigate with โ†‘ โ†“Enter to openEsc to close

Challenge the benchmark

Choose a score and give the benchmark a specific reason to reconsider it.

When you submit, the form attaches the current score and confidence for the country and capability you chose.

Submissions are public and start as awaiting review. A maintainer can add a response and signature after review.

Documented examples

Each record describes something a country built that the indicators do not capture. The source provides the published number; the mechanism is our interpretation.

Scores describe outcomes. These records describe how a country acted, what it needed and what happened. 742 of 742 records include a mechanism. They do not affect scores.

Narrow the list

8 of 742 deliveries

Coordination

2 deliveries linked to University-industry collaboration, Public-private collaboration.

Philippinessince 2017still operatingbears on University-industry collaboration

CRADLE, DOST's collaborative R&D grant for academe and companies

From 2017 the Department of Science and Technology's CRADLE programme funded 82 projects in which a university or research institute did R&D on a problem set by a Filipino company, worth 373.6 million pesos and involving 36 HEIs or RDIs and 83 companies by early 2022.

82 projects, cradle projects funded since 2017, 2022. 373,600,000 Philippine pesos, value of cradle projects funded since 2017, 2022. Department of Science and Technology (DOST), Science for Change Program, CRADLE call for proposals for CY 2023 funding, retrieved 2026-10-02.

The move, and what it needed

DOST pays for an R&D project only when a Filipino company names the problem, commits counterpart funding and agrees to adopt the result, and a university or research institute does the research.

Preconditions

  • University and RDI researchers able to work on applied industrial problems
  • Companies willing to co-fund and commit to adopting the result
  • A public grant line, here the Science for Change Program, that can contract with both sides

Where else it has been used: The design is close to Turkey's TรœBฤฐTAK 1505 and Malaysia's PPRN: the firm states the problem and shares the cost. DOST later added an industry-led variant, iCRADLE, for larger consortia.

Limits: The figures are DOST's own, stated in a call for proposals rather than an audited annual report, and they are cumulative from 2017 to the date of the call (March 2022), so no single year can be read off them. The number sits inside a PDF, on page 1. A funded project is an input: the document does not say how many were completed, how many technologies the partner companies adopted, or what the companies paid as their required counterpart of at least 20 percent. 82 projects over five years is small against the size of the Philippine economy, and the partner pool includes public research institutes as well as universities. No newer official count was found: the operating status rests on DOST's undated S4CP programme page, which still describes CRADLE as being implemented, so the 2022 figures may understate the programme's current size.

Philippinessince 2018still operatingbears on Public-private collaboration

InstaPay under the National Retail Payment System

InstaPay, the real-time automated clearing house organized under the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas' National Retail Payment System framework, in which banks and e-money issuers take part, processed 4.7 billion transfers worth โ‚ฑ11.6 trillion in 2025, up from 232.9 million in 2020, with 95 participating institutions in July 2026.

4,700,000,000 transactions, instapay transactions in the year, 2025. 11,600,000,000,000 Philippine pesos, instapay transaction value in the year, 2025. Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas, Payments Bulletin (data as of July 2026), retrieved 2026-10-02.

The move, and what it needed

The central bank set an interoperability framework requiring retail payment providers to join industry-run automated clearing houses, while banks and e-money issuers governed the clearing rules through a self-regulatory payment management body, so any account or wallet could pay any other in real time.

Preconditions

  • A central bank willing to mandate interoperability but delegate rule-making to an industry body.
  • Mobile e-money issuers large enough to bring unbanked users onto the rail.
  • A national QR standard (QR Ph) to carry the rail to merchants.

Where else it has been used: The arrangement resembles Thailand's PromptPay and India's UPI in the corpus, with a stronger role for industry self-governance.

Limits: Transaction counts show a heavily used rail, not who uses it: a large part of the 2025 jump (230.9 percent in volume against 57.3 percent in value) is consistent with small e-wallet cash-ins and transfers, so value per transfer fell, and the bulletin does not split person-to-person use from wallet top-ups. The participant count (87 sender-receivers and eight receive-only) is computed from the bulletin's table. The bulletin lists InstaPay among the payment systems organized under the National Retail Payment System and lists its participants by type, but does not say who operates or governs the clearing house, so the industry side of the arrangement rests on sources outside this bulletin. The 2018 start year is not stated in the bulletin, whose annual table begins in 2020. The central bank's 2024 digital payments report puts digital at 57.4 percent of retail payment volume, so cash still carries a large share. The bulletin is a slide deck PDF: the annual table is on page 6 and the participant table on page 5. bsp.gov.ph refuses scripted requests (Akamai 'Access Denied'); the PDF was read through WebFetch at the same URL. The central bank reports on a framework it regulates.

Learning

1 delivery linked to Adult learning participation.

Philippinessince 1994still operatingbears on Adult learning participation

TESDA technical-vocational training at national scale

The Philippines' Technical Education and Skills Development Authority, created in 1994, recorded 1,633,393 enrollees and 1,428,724 graduates in technical-vocational education and training across all regions in 2023, with enrollment 29.61% above 2022.

1,633,393 people, tvet enrollees, 2023. 29.61 %, increase in tvet enrollees compared with 2022, 2023. Technical Education and Skills Development Authority (TESDA), Annual TVET Statistics 2023, retrieved 2026-10-01.

The move, and what it needed

The Philippines merged its manpower council, technical-education bureau and apprenticeship office into one authority that sets training regulations, registers public and private providers, funds scholarships and certifies competencies, so a national skills system runs through thousands of local providers under one standard.

Preconditions

  • Promulgated competency standards and an assessment-and-certification system employers recognise
  • A network of public training institutes plus regulated private providers that reaches every region
  • Scholarship funding that can be scaled up and down with labour-market needs without collapsing provider capacity

Where else it has been used: Unified TVET authorities with competency-based certification echo Australia's and Singapore's models; the Philippine case shows the scale such a body can reach while leaving labour-market relevance a separate test.

Limits: The gap asks for the share of adults in training in the last 12 months; this is a count of enrollments, not a population share, and the record does not compute one. Enrollments are not unique people: one person taking two courses counts twice, and the figure includes young people entering the labour market for the first time as well as adults returning to learning. The counts are TESDA's own administrative statistics, covering public and registered private providers; informal and employer training outside TESDA registration is missing, and course length ranges from short modules to multi-month programmes. A 29.61% rise in one year partly reflects recovery from the pandemic years and scholarship budget swings, so year-on-year growth is not a trend. The source is a PDF statistical report, not an API, and it shows output, not employment or wage effects.

Adaptability

3 deliveries linked to Institutional responsiveness, Disaster preparedness and recovery.

Philippinessince 2018still operatingbears on Institutional responsiveness

PhilSys foundational national ID rollout

The Philippine Statistics Authority reported 90,017,565 people registered to PhilSys by 19 September 2024, or 97.8% of the year's 92 million registration target, with the ID designed for government and private-sector transactions.

90,017,565 people, people registered to philsys, 2024-09-19. 92,000,000 people, 2024 registration target, 2024. Philippine Statistics Authority, PhilSys 90-million registration press release, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

The Philippines made one permanent identifier the base for public and private transactions, combined PSA registration with mobile and local-government channels and added physical, paper and digital credentials so the system could reach people with different levels of connectivity.

Preconditions

  • A civil-registration authority able to reconcile demographic and biometric records at national scale
  • Registration sites and mobile teams that can reach islands, remote barangays and young children
  • Clear legal rules and relying-party integration so the credential is accepted beyond the issuing agency

Where else it has been used: Foundational IDs travel when enrolment, authentication and service integration are funded as one system. PhilSys shows how quickly registration can scale, while delivery and acceptance remain separate tests.

Limits: Registration against a target shows the reach of an identity enrolment campaign, not whether records are accurate, cards arrive promptly, agencies actually accept the credential or people receive better services. The PSA reports the milestone and target; this record does not independently assess exclusion, privacy or authentication performance.

Philippinessince 2008still operatingbears on Institutional responsiveness

Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program (4Ps)

The Philippines' 4Ps conditional cash-transfer programme reached 4,064,354 households by 30 June 2024 across 41,746 barangays, 148 cities and 1,485 municipalities, with beneficiaries linked to health, education and nutrition conditions.

4,064,354 households, 4ps households reached, 2024-06-30. 41,746 barangays, barangays covered by 4ps, 2024-06-30. Department of Social Welfare and Development, 4Ps second-quarter 2024 implementation report, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

The Philippines combined a national household-targeting system with conditional grants, local verification and regular programme monitoring, allowing a central social-protection rule to operate through thousands of barangays and municipal service networks.

Preconditions

  • A household registry that can be updated as poverty, migration and family composition change
  • Schools, health facilities and local governments able to verify conditions without making remote families carry the full administrative burden
  • Payment and grievance channels that let beneficiaries correct records and challenge missed or suspended grants

Where else it has been used: Conditional transfers travel through local service capacity. The Philippine case is useful because its national scale makes the registry, verification and grievance machinery visible rather than treating the cash grant as the whole programme.

Limits: Household and barangay coverage show administrative reach, not whether payments arrive on time, children attend school, health outcomes improve or eligible families are excluded. The implementation report is the programme's own account and does not replace an independent causal evaluation or measure the quality of local services that conditions depend on.

Philippinessince 2013still operatingbears on Disaster preparedness and recovery

Typhoon Yolanda shelter and recovery programme

After Typhoon Yolanda, the Philippines' recovery programme had provided shelter assistance to about 1.14 million families by September 2016; the National Housing Authority had completed 29,661 permanent units while 102,240 more were under construction across six regions, 14 provinces and 115 cities and municipalities.

1,140,000 families, families receiving emergency shelter assistance, 2016-09. 29,661 units, permanent housing units completed, 2016-09. National Economic and Development Authority, Philippine Development Plan chapter on building safe communities, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

The Philippines combined emergency shelter assistance with a multi-agency recovery plan, permanent housing and local-government coordination, while documenting the land, permitting and procurement bottlenecks that slowed the transition from relief to safer settlement.

Preconditions

  • A recovery authority able to coordinate national agencies, local governments, donors and affected communities
  • Pre-agreed land, titling and no-build-zone rules that can be activated after a disaster
  • Monitoring that tracks completed and occupied units, not just funds released or houses contracted

Where else it has been used: Disaster recovery travels as a governance sequence: cash and shelter first, then land, housing and livelihoods. Yolanda is valuable because its implementation record shows both the reach and the friction in that sequence.

Limits: The figures are a 2016 implementation snapshot, not a final account of long-term recovery, land tenure, livelihoods, relocation quality or resilience to the next storm. The same source records major housing delays caused by no-build zones, land conversion, titling and local approvals; shelter counts therefore should not be read as proof that recovery was complete or equitable.

Building

2 deliveries linked to Large project delivery.

Philippinessince 2016still operatingbears on Large project delivery

DPWH national infrastructure delivery and transparency portal

The Philippine Department of Public Works and Highways' live transparency portal records 209,419 completed contracts and 997 terminated contracts out of 258,645 contracts from 2016 to 2026, against โ‚ฑ6.4 trillion of listed investment.

209,419 contracts, completed dpwh contracts, 2026. 997 contracts, terminated dpwh contracts, 2026. Philippine Department of Public Works and Highways, infrastructure transparency portal, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

DPWH exposed a national project portfolio with contract, cost, accomplishment and completion fields, making delivery status inspectable across regions instead of leaving infrastructure performance inside agency spreadsheets and press releases.

Preconditions

  • A common project and contract identifier shared by national and district engineering offices
  • Field reporting and audit practices strong enough to keep accomplishment and termination statuses current
  • A public interface that lets citizens, contractors and oversight bodies compare commitments with delivered works

Where else it has been used: Project transparency travels when it is attached to contract data and corrections, not only a dashboard of completed works. The Philippines provides a useful portfolio-scale example while leaving cost and quality verification open.

Limits: Contract status and listed investment reveal portfolio scale and a public reporting mechanism, not whether projects met their original cost, schedule, quality or maintenance promises. The portal's totals are live and can change as records are uploaded or corrected; they are not an independent value-for-money audit.

Philippinessince 1976dismantledbears on Large project delivery

Bataan Nuclear Power Plant, a mothballed megaproject

The Philippine Department of Energy's 2017 annual report describes the Bataan Nuclear Power Plant as mothballed and records its reassessment as part of a proposed national nuclear programme, after the original plant failed to become an operating power asset.

1 plant, mothballed nuclear power plants reassessed, 2017. Philippine Department of Energy, 2017 Energy Annual Report, retrieved 2026-08-31.

The move, and what it needed

The Philippines carried a completed but mothballed nuclear asset into later policy reviews instead of treating construction as equivalent to usable capability; the plant became a long-lived governance and maintenance obligation while the country reconsidered nuclear power.

Preconditions

  • Independent safety and technical institutions able to reassess a politically sensitive sunk asset
  • A transparent process for comparing rehabilitation with closure and alternative generation
  • Long-term funding and site stewardship for a facility that does not produce electricity

Where else it has been used: Megaprojects can fail at the conversion from physical completion to operating capability. Bataan is a useful negative case because it keeps construction, commissioning and usable service as separate tests.

Limits: The report establishes the plant's mothballed status and later reassessment, but not the full historical cost, safety case, debt burden or counterfactual electricity supply. The record concerns the original plant as a delivery outcome; later feasibility studies and nuclear-policy discussions are separate decisions, not evidence that the original project operated.